November 03, 2026
Incentives and intentional plan design have long been used to encourage engagement with health and well-being programs and guide employees toward higher-value care. As employers face continued pressure to manage rising healthcare costs, many are taking a closer look at what these strategies intend to accomplish, how to measure their impact, and when stronger approaches to incentives and steerage may be appropriate.
The following provides a recap of the approaches, challenges, and considerations shared by employers.
Incentive Strategies Are Shifting Toward More Purposeful Engagement
Many employers are holding their well-being incentive strategies relatively steady for 2027 while evaluating more substantial changes for 2028. This reassessment of the role of incentives reflects broader questions about whether incentives meaningfully drive behavior change or primarily reward employees who are already engaged and healthy. In the near term, some employers are making targeted adjustments, such as requiring proof of completed biometric screenings rather than employee attestation. Employers are also more likely to tie incentives to specific health actions, such as establishing a relationship with a primary care provider (PCP) or following up on biometric screening results, to engage employees who otherwise may not have taken these steps.
Measuring the Impact and Value of Incentives Remains Challenging
For many employers, demonstrating the impact of incentive programs on behaviors and long-term health outcomes remains difficult. While a handful of employers have been able to demonstrate lower claims costs for employees who participate in incentive programs vs. those who do not, they recognize that healthier employees are more likely to engage with incentives to begin with and that lower claims costs could be attributed to a variety of factors, making it difficult to determine whether the incentive itself drove those differences. As a result, employers are looking beyond return on investment (ROI) to measures such as program participation, primary and preventive care utilization, risk scores, emergency department and inpatient utilization, and other activities aligned with employees’ health needs. Some are also using these insights to inform incentive design; for example, a claims analysis showing lower costs among employees engaged with primary care helped inform an employer’s decision to add an incentive for establishing a PCP connection. Employers are also balancing the fact that incentives can lead to an uptick in short-term plan utilization, which may identify health risks earlier and encourage appropriate care but can also raise short-term healthcare costs. Nonetheless, employers noted that this short-term increase is well worth it if the utilization can create healthy habits and catch risks early.
Weighing Steerage Strategies Against Employee Experience
Several employers use thoughtful plan design to guide employees toward primary care, preventive care, and higher-value providers. Strategies include premium reductions, lower or $0 cost sharing, steerage to centers of excellence (COEs), travel benefits, tiered networks, and requirements for selected procedures (for example, bariatric surgery). In general, experiences with voluntary and mandatory steerage vary across employee populations. Voluntary approaches preserve employee choice but may result in lower participation, while mandatory approaches can strengthen steerage but create challenges related to existing provider relationships, travel, access barriers, and employee experience implications. Many employers noted that over the next year they will consider stricter steerage approaches, particularly in cases when employees can be identified early on in their care journey.
Outlook
The call underscored how employers are becoming more intentional about matching incentives and plan design to the healthy behavior they want to influence. As cost pressures and market volatility continue, measuring success of steerage and incentive strategies may therefore necessitate adopting a more holistic view of value that considers engagement, appropriate utilization, and health outcomes alongside financial impact.
Related Resources
- Podcast: Designing the "Carrot” in Incentive Programs so that Behaviors Stick
- Designing Incentives and Lifestyle Spending Accounts For a Modern Workforce
- Center of Excellence Considerations for Employers
- Summary of Key Opportunities for Employers to Advance Preventive Care